Last time I discussed, in my own disorganised way, my thoughts on 7″ hex tiles. Now I’m going to delve into the 4″ hex tile. As I’ve stated a few times before the thought first came to me when I saw the Tabletop Hex Terrain Toolkit on Kickstarter. This is going to be a great tool for making some wonderful terrain for both RPG’s and Wargames. However the scale is just slightly off for my tastes (as discussed here). I may eventually redesign the tool for use with proper one inch horizontal hexes, until then I am making four inch tiles to use for my GURPS Dungeon Fantasy games.
The 4″ Tiles can only support single and double width corridors (1 hex = 3′) compared to the three widths in the 7″ tiles. Also the number of connections is reduced dramatically to the four examples in the following image, compared to the 9 images for 7″ tiles.
Corridor options
Although there are fewer options I don’t think the four inch tiles are inferior to the seven inch. The four inch tiles will certainly allow for more dense dungeons, and with a bit of thought and planning will be able to offer some very complex designs. Also you can make any Hex Dungeon look just like any Square dungeon. All it takes is manipulating the width of the horizontal corridors. If the corridors are the same width they will not match up when a horizontal corridor attaches to a vertical corridor. The horizontal corridor will be too wide.
Both horizontal and vertical corridors are the same width, the horizontal is too wide
The horizontal corridor is now slightly smaller than the vertical. H: 3.43, V: 3.9
I can live with this slight alteration as it now gives me more options when designing. I can now have corridors that turn at 90° just like you would with a square tiled dungeon.
90° left hand turn
Single width corridors and room tiles, just a fraction of the possibilities
An example of what can be made 1 hex = 3′ (1 meter)
What I like from the example above is how at any given time the orientation of the dungeon can turn 60° giving the dungeon a more natural feel. If you’re digging a dungeon why would you limit yourself to a grid? Also once you add the double width corridors your increasing your options and complexity. I’ll be adding more as I have time.
I’ve got plans to make full 3D dungeons using the 4 inch tiles and plaster molds such as those you can get from Hirst Arts, Linka World, and 4bot Industries. The issue is I will have to make a lot of custom pieces and custom molds so I’m going to be shelving this project for the mean time.
I think switching from the 7″ to the 4″ tiles was the right choice for me. When I get time I will go ahead and place the 30+ 7″ colour tiles I’ve already made if anyone is interested in trying them out. I’ll do the same for the 4″ but not until I get a large amount ready.
Pro
- You can make dense dungeons without so many extra tiles
- Easier to store
- Can produce more random results
- Easier to use “Fog of War” effect
Con
- Only single and double wide corridors, no triple
- No irregular/offset corridors
- Floor textures may not align properly
- Custom 3D parts
How are your designs different from http://nogarung.com/hexomorfo/en/ ?
Well if you look at http://gurps.dungeoncrawlers.com/2017/03/my-thoughts-on-4-hex-tiles/ you will see that I have both horizontal and vertical corridors in my tiles. Also I have a few different width corridors which was explained in the blog posts. This is something I did with my 7 inch tiles back in 2011: http://gurps.dungeoncrawlers.com/2011/09/circular-geomorph-tests/ you can read about all the differnt options you can do with 7 inch tiles here: http://gurps.dungeoncrawlers.com/2017/03/my-thoughts-on-7-hex-battle-tiles/
I’ve been working on Hex Dungeons on and off since 2009. I had already a large amount of both 4″ and 7″ hex tiles in progress before hexomorfo was announced. I’m not going to stop tinkering with hex tile ideas, it is a hobby of mine. I love the art design of Hexomorfo, but I don’t draw to well so mine will be made in Campaign Cartographer like all my other hex dungeons over the last eight years. Whether I ever get around to releasing them? Who knows.